Archive for October, 2007

In the midst of my busyness…

October 29, 2007 at 12:03 pm · Filed under My Oboe Playing, Oboe Reeds

… I managed to begin a little experiment.

First off, the concert went well last night. Theofanidis Rainbow Body, Symphonie Fantastique, Danse Macabre amongst others.

One of my reed subscribers sent me two reeds made by a well-known Mack student professor along with 10 staples and the same Mack+ shaper tip that the professor uses. My instructions were to duplicate it as close as I can.

I’ve made about 6 reeds on my own staples but using “hard cane” (as instructed) and using the Mack+ shape and matching the proportions and lengths exactly as the two reeds. All of my reeds play close to 20 cents flat, and require a LOT of blowing up to pitch and “extreme reed pressure” (and sometimes biting), but they certainly get a bit more of a covered Mackish sound. In fact, I played my concert on one of these reeds last night (lipping it up to pitch, of course).

Flat reeds always sound great when you can get them up to pitch, but usually they’re just that. Flat. But it has been a very good experiment for me to remind me of WHY I don’t like playing flat reeds and WHY I don’t like lipping up reeds constantly. I can already feel the wear on my lip after about 3 days of playing on these reeds, and I’m starting to get some jaw pain reminiscent of my TMJ problems. I practiced my Malcolm Arnold Sonatina with my tuner on a flat reed this morning and was able to get through the piece okay, but I wasn’t able to do the dynamic contrasts, color changes and variety of articulations that I wanted to, because I was squeezing the reed so tightly with my lips.

Mr. Stolper used to tell me that Tabuteau had a picture of an inverted triangle (smallest part down) in his office.  At the top was the word “response”. Below that was “stability/pitch” and below that at the smallest point was “tone”.

The more I play and the more I hear, I am becoming convinced that in a big hall small tonal discrepancies disappear, and what the listener will listen for the most is what you do with the music, not your tonal quality on the music. And if I have to play a reed with great tone but can’t do much with it, then it’s probably just not worth it.

Comments (3)

Busy!

October 24, 2007 at 3:19 pm · Filed under Uncategorized

Wind Ensemble concerts! Symphony concerts! Lots of things going on. I’ve been too busy to spend some serious time on reeds, and too busy to write much about practicing and playing, but I can tell you this… I’M REALLY TIRED!!!

Leave a Comment

Music Quote

October 18, 2007 at 7:10 am · Filed under Interviews

Music alone contains the all-important secret of separating the soul from all mortal cares for at least as long as the notes can keep it absorbed, through the skillful management of consance, whether vocal or instrumental. And if sleep is so universally praised for its power to enthrall the senses of unhappy humanity, lifting them up and, for a few hours, making them impervious to misfortune, how much more praiseworthy must an art be which, not robbing us life as does sleep (when it is called the Brother of Death), allows us to live ecstatically in delicious, contented peace, our senses fully about us, yet glad and truly blissful. This art… deserves to have voices, instruments, poetry, painting, architecture, mechanics, mimic, and any other art pay court to it and obey it.

- Pier Jacopo Martello, 1715

Leave a Comment

Choice of music…

October 18, 2007 at 7:04 am · Filed under My Oboe Playing

So I narrowed my jury music down to 5 pieces. I have to jury once every 10 weeks here at Oregon, which seems a bit over the top to me, but thus is required so there’s no use in arguing over it.

  • Five French Contemporary Recital Pieces – Multiple Composers
  • Oblivion – Piazolla
  • Black Anemones – Schwantner
  • Sonatina – Malcolm Arnold
  • Suite – Walter Piston

Mack recorded some of the Five French Contemporary pieces on his CD with the Romances and Saint Saens. Oblivion and Black Anemones are on Rebecca Henderson’s CD. The Piston Suite is on Robinson’s CD, and the Sonatina is Jeffrey Rathbun’s Color Factory CD.

After a bit of consulting with my professor, I went with my first reaction which was to go for the Malcolm Arnold. It’s a lovely piece, and isn’t performed very much, but has a lot of energy and excitement. I’m looking forward to delving into the work.

Comments (3)

Is English Horn supposed to be played this way?

October 13, 2007 at 10:22 am · Filed under Uncategorized

So I recently called Mr. Weber and discussed my EH reed problems. My big problem was that I have to play a middle C on this piece (Concert F, fingered C) at ppp for 20 or 30 measures, and in doing so, it sound buzzy, and light, and ugly. Mr. Weber suggested that I review his reedmaker manual, and summarized some major points:

  • Thicker tips
  • Thinner hearts (proportionally)
  • Smoother integration line
  • Wire 5mm above the string, just to support the upper notes and not to be used for the opening, gently squeezing the sides of the blades.
  • Thinnest part of the windows directly above the bark (opposed to just behind the heart)

(Granted, for all you EH reed people, I never profess to be good at EH reedmaking, but I can do it. I’m still trying to “separate myself from oboe” and “learn how to make EH reeds that don’t resemble big oboe reeds”. But you keep ordering them, so I keep trying to make them!)

This last bullet I had completely forgotten and now makes sense. One needs to scrape the extreme back of the windows to close that part down so that the air can properly channel into the staple. That’s why when you have an extremely thick-sided oboe gouge, you end up compromising the structural integrity of the reed by gouging out the same place – just above the bark – in order to close down the back of the reed and channel the air correctly.

So the reeds are working, but they’re requiring a lot firmer embouchure, and steadier air stream. I wonder if this is how the EH is actually supposed to be.

Comments (2)

Weber 1-C continued

October 12, 2007 at 10:09 am · Filed under Uncategorized

So my client in Atlanta liked his 1-C better than his 1-B, which he’s been ordering for 3 or 4 months now. And I’ve been scraping up several 1-Cs which are all coming out “Just right”. This is very surprising for me, since I’ve never had such great results.

  • Is my playing changing?
  • Have I changed my scrape?
  • Has the climate change affected the reeds?

Do people use wider shapes in autumn and fall and thinner shapes in spring and summer? I don’t recall doing this, but I certainly wonder.

Leave a Comment

When things are out of whack…

October 10, 2007 at 11:26 pm · Filed under Oboe Reeds

I return to my standards.

  • Graf #1 gouge
  • Weber 1-B shape
  • Grimaud Cane

But what happens when my standards aren’t living up to par? Then I need to play around with one of these variables. So I changed shape.

  • Graf #1 gouge
  • Weber 1-C shape
  • Grimaud Cane

Lo and behold, I got some pretty darn good results! Several of them! I decided to pull out the ole’ Weber 1-C shape because I’ve been thickening my sides up a bit, but began getting some “inflexible” results, which forced me to take more and more and more cane off, thus compromising the structural integrity of the reed. I wasn’t very happy with these results, because my openings got smaller and smaller. Well, with the 1-C, peace and order were restored. But then I started thinking…

“Hm… But my Graf #2 is set up for the 1-C…”

So I changed that.

  • Graf #2
  • Weber 1-C shape
  • Grimaud Cane

My initial measurements of the cane coming of the Graf #1 and Graf #2 were almost identical (but obviously the curve isn’t). And of course, the reed on the Graf #2 worked great as well.

So now this makes me think I need to go back and start thinning the sides of the Graf #1 to restore order so that it clicks well with my Weber 1-B.

Sigh… gouging machines give me a headache.

Leave a Comment

Shaping techiques

October 8, 2007 at 10:09 pm · Filed under Reader Questions/Responses

A reader, sparked by Patty’s post, wrote me with a few questions:


- Do you use a new one each time, or sharpen them?

Yes, I use a new one each time.

Mr. Weber says you can resharpen them…
- Why a razor blade, why not just an old reed knife
without a burr?

Mr. Weber likes to sharpen a razor blade down to a thicker part of the steel. I would never use an old reed knife, because I don’t think you could get it sharp enough to have a clean, even cut.

To answer the second question retorically. One
teacher I had (as well as most books) suggest a razor
blade, but I’ve never heard the reasoning. I do know
professional oboists that just use an old reed knife.
I’ve recently been doing a science experiment. When I
shape cane, I’ll shape 1/3 with new razor blades, 1/3
with old sharpened razor blades, and 1/3 with a
sharpened no-burr reed knife.

Now granted, shaper tips are not all the same. Some shaper tips really encourage a better shape up by the ears and how that curve shape is. But again, I would never use a reed knife. It’d be too thick of a blade, which wouldn’t allow you to get close enough to the shape without putting too much torque on the cane as it comes off. It’d rip the cane off.

Comments (6)

Carol Wincenc Masterclass

October 6, 2007 at 1:23 pm · Filed under University of Oregon School of Music

I just got back from a Masterclass with Carol Wincenc, faculty on Juilliard, world renowned flute soloist, and teacher extraordinaire. It was certainly one of the more rewarding masterclasses I have ever attended, and found her both inspiring as well kind-hearted.

From a musical stand point, she did things with the flute that I simply didn’t know were possible. Her wide dynamic capability and the ability to change tonal colors on a dime (literally, from black to white) were incredible, and I came away with a heightened sense of musical awareness. One very interesting aspect was her emphasis on air control and where it came from. She said she never breathes through her nose, and that she always expands the lower back. I’ve heard of this concept from both Martin Schuring and Joe Robinson, but never quite got it all the way. I’d say my breathing comes from closer to my stomach. In any case, all of the above mentioned breath expanding your lower back (below the rib cage) outward. Interesting.

I picked up a few of her CDs. If anyone gets a chance to take in a masterclass with her, certainly do so.

Comments (2)

My back problems.

October 6, 2007 at 12:17 am · Filed under Uncategorized

So I went to a chiropractor today who discussed my reedmaking, oboe playing, and back problems. He took some x-rays, which revealed this:

  • My bad posture has hurt my a lot.
  • When I scrape, I lift up my right arm to get a better angle, sometimes perpendicular from my torso. Holding it at such an awkward often tightens up the muscles, and gets them wrapped up in knots. This has also overdeveloped my right shoulder muscles, which are now elevated in relation to my left shoulder muscles. When these muscles get strained, they push down on my vertebrae.
  • My vertebrae have calcium deposits on them which lock them into place even further, which limits my flexibility.
  • I have a bulging disk right in my upper back (between the shoulder blades) which allows the vertebrae to compress even further. This is pinching a nerve in my right arm where I’m losing mobility and general nerve feeling.

He says regular chiropractic care can improve my posture and relieve pressure on the bulging disk. He also said occasionally calcium deposits go away, but not often.

Thank God my health insurance from my Teaching Fellowship is fantastic and covers Chiropractic, Dental, and everything else.

Comments (3)

Older Posts »